BackCallers' Workshop — Enthusing, Encouraging and Influencing



  Before I mention the topic I go round the group and ask people to say in one sentence why they enjoy dancing.  It's an idea I picked up from Bruce Hamilton who is a real thinking caller.  People give all sorts of reasons, and then he says something like, “So you see how many reasons people have for dancing.  It's your job as a caller to satisfy as many of their needs as you can, rather than just focusing on why you enjoy dancing.”

Enthusing   Print this section

I have a set of notes on the topic “Why do we dance?” and it's worth repeating the introduction here.

If you've been dancing for years and years, it's probably a question you never ask yourself!  Maybe you should.  Do you just dance because you've been doing it for years?  Are you still looking for the same things you were looking for when you started dancing?  …

The obvious answer is “I dance because I enjoy it” — but that just leads on to the next question: Why do you enjoy it?  What is it about dancing that makes it so special?

That was aimed at dancers, but I'm talking to callers here.  What can we do as individual callers — not as part of some committee — to enthuse dancers when we call at our local clubs or wherever?

  I first ask for suggestions before giving my own ideas.

  The first thing is, we have to be enthusiastic — and yet a lot of callers aren't.  They may be good technically, but they're boring!  Don't be a boring caller!  Never forget, you are a performer.  In 2018 when Mike Courthold was Dance Director at Chippenham Folk Festival he sent out a set of notes to the callers a few days before the weekend, and his final point was:

In all of your workshops and dances, remember that we are first and foremost entertainers.

That doesn't mean you have to do a song and dance routine.  Alan Davies objected to this definition and would say scornfully “I am not a clown”.  Nor was Pavarotti, but he was certainly an entertainer.  Alan could get people through really complicated dances, but he didn't entertain them.  Some callers tell jokes — Pete Hendy was well-known for that.  I don't, though I hope my humour arises naturally from the situation.  And it's spontaneous, which means sometimes I wish I hadn't said what I did!

So what else can we do to enthuse people?

  You need to be good at your job when walking through and calling the dance.  You want people to think that you're a nice chap, who won't jump on them if they make the slightest mistake, and who's willing to admit his own mistakes without apologising for the next twenty minutes.  You want to put the dancers at their ease — how can they enjoy the dancing if they're not?

  Talk up the dance.  If you say “This is a great dance”, people are quite likely to believe you.  Or you might say it has a great tune and the dance really fits it.  Whereas if you say “I picked this up last Saturday, never tried it before, I don't know what you'll think of it” they're likely to be less keen.  I've heard Barbara Kinsman say, “I know you don't like waltz dances, so we'll only do a few turns”.  What sort of message is that giving out?!  I also heard her say something like “I expect you're all fed up with this one”, and it was actually a dance I'd never heard of, but apparently lots of people had been calling it in her area.

  With recorded music — Listen to your recordings and ask whether they make you want to dance.  I was once sent a cassette by a band I didn't know, and on the cover photo they all looked bored as hell!  I guessed that their music would be just as boring, and I was right.

  With live music — Unless you're a well-known caller you probably won't get a choice of band.  So find out what they're good at playing, and give them plenty of that, even if it's not your usual style.  I always send a band a programme well in advance, and I say “Let me know any of these tunes you don't want to play, and any others you really do want to play”.  And bands often thank me for giving them lots of good tunes to play — a happy band can contribute enormously to the success of the evening and the enthusiasm of the dancers.  Talk up the band.  Don't say they were great if they weren't, but find some things that they've played well and tell the crowd how well they played them.

  I believe that if you get people dancing well — and praise them for it — that makes them enthusiastic.  I know some people aren't interested in dancing well, and you have to face the fact that you're never going to make an impact on them whatever you do, but that doesn't mean you give up trying — it may take a long time, but suddenly you notice a real improvement and that makes it all worthwhile.

  Remember, this is social dancing not training a display team, and people may come as much for the social aspect as for the dancing itself, so don't stop them talking if they really want to talk to each other.  You may think that your job is to get through twelve dances in an evening, but they don't see it that way.  Tony Parkes suggests that you get the sets formed up and then let them chat for a couple of minutes.  Admittedly you do have to shut them up eventually, but try not to sound like a school-teacher.  I find if you just wait, some people on the floor will realise you want to continue and they'll do the shutting up for you.  But don't then spoil it by some sarcastic remark like “Well I'm gratified that you've decided to listen at last” — just start the walkthrough and keep your calm.

  Another aspect of social dancing is getting people to switch partners though this may meet with resistance, but at least suggest it now and then.

  Send them home happy!  If it's a club who always expect to finish with “Devil's Dream” or “Circassian Circle”, this is not the time to announce, “I'm going to finish with one I've just written — I think it should work”.  Just go with the flow: find a really lively recording or get the band to play their liveliest set of jigs and reels.  Brian Stanton called a Saturday Dance for my local club and did quite a challenging first half (which certainly enthused me), but part-way through the second half he dropped the level down considerably.  Another dancer asked me whether I'd noticed this, and I explained the principle behind it: if people have trouble with the last dance, they'll go home remembering it was a difficult evening!  That may be unfair, but it's the way people's minds work.  Similarly you want something sure-fire to end the first half, or people have the whole interval to mutter to each other about it — and you won't even know unless you have a spy in the dancers' camp.  If you want more information , read about the Peak-end rule which says that people judge an experience largely based on how they felt at its peak (i.e., its most intense point) and at its end, rather than based on the total sum or average of every moment of the experience.  The effect occurs whether the experience is pleasant or unpleasant.

Encouraging   Print this section   Top of page

I have a set of notes for dancers called Dancing without Fear and I want to go through some of those points from the caller's point of view.  Suppose you have some new or fairly new dancers: what can you say to encourage them?  Don't be glib and say “This is an easy little dance” — no it isn't to them.

  If there's time, talk to any new dancers — introduce yourself as the caller and find out a bit about them — what kind of dancing they've done before, how they heard about this event, just general chat.  Explain that you'll be walking the dance through so that everybody has got it before you launch into the music.  Try to persuade them to sit near the top of the hall and get up quick to be near the top of the set where there are usually good dancers to help them — you may not be able to manage this though!

  Tell them it's OK to go wrong.  Some actors recording a television programme deliberately make a mistake early on in the process so that the audience can see that it's very easy for the actor to say to the director, “Sorry, I fluffed that line — can I do it again?”  and the director just says “OK” and then the audience realise they don't need to be tense wondering if anything is going to go wrong and spoil the recording, so they can relax and enjoy the show.  I'm not suggesting you should deliberately make mistakes — most of us don't need to do that deliberately! — but let the crowd know that you can make mistakes and so can they.  If you're working with live music and you have a good relationship with the musicians you can add “And even the band make mistakes occasionally”.  The band may rise to this and protest that they're perfect, but people will realise it's all done in fun and the message gets through: It's OK to make mistakes.

  Take the time to explain the formation, and the progression.  In a longways duple dance, explain that you take hands four to see which couple you're dancing with and which way you're progressing.  If I'm doing a newcomers' session before the dance starts I might well do: “Circle left once around.  Balance the ring; pass through to the next couple”.  I just sing out the rhythm — I don't need any music played — and they get the idea of working with this couple, progressing to the next couple, being neutral at either end, coming in as the other number, and maybe even fitting the moves to the rhythm of the music.  You may find some people who think they're good dancers complaining, “Yes, we know all this”, but you'll never find a really good dancer saying that: they realise new people need to get their heads round this completely new concept — they won't have seen anything like it in disco dancing, line dancing, ballroom dancing, Argentine Tango, Ceroc…  And once they've grasped it, they should have an idea of where they ought to be when the next turn of the dance starts.

  As you're walking it through, try to get the dancers to see the logic of it.  A dance isn't just a random set of figures strung together.  Show them how one move flows into the next, rather than leaving a long gap between each.  Also point out where the progression occurs.  Cecil Sharp always says progression at the crucial point.  I'd never realised why he was so insistent about that until I started writing my notes, and then it occurred to me that if you're new to this it's something to cling on to.  “I have progressed.  I was there — now I'm here.  This is my new place.”

  At the end of the evening I try to talk to them, tell them they've been doing well, and point out that they've had a load of new stuff thrown at them in a short time, but it really does get easier after a few weeks.  These moves you've met tonight like “Set and turn single” or “Balance and swing” or “Hey for four” appear in hundreds of dances.  You don't need to remember the dances; you just need to know how to do the figures.

Influencing   Print this section   Top of page

I've been reading an amazing book called “Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion”.  It was originally published in 1984, long before Internet Influencers (in fact long before the Internet), but it's still hugely topical.  It explains the various ways salesmen and other people persuade us to do things we really don't want to do, and it shows us how to be aware of their tactics and circumvent them, but also how to use them ourselves.

From the description on Amazon:

In this highly acclaimed New York Times bestseller, Dr. Robert B. Cialdini — the seminal expert in the field of influence and persuasion — explains the psychology of why people say yes and how to apply these principles ethically in business and everyday situations.

You'll learn the six universal principles of influence and how to use them to become a skilled persuader — and, just as importantly, how to defend yourself against dishonest influence attempts:

  • Reciprocation: The internal pull to repay what another person has provided us.
  • Commitment and Consistency: Once we make a choice or take a stand, we work to behave consistently with that commitment in order to justify our decisions.
  • Social Proof: When we are unsure, we look to similar others to provide us with the correct actions to take.  And the more people undertaking that action, the more we consider that action correct.
  • Liking: The propensity to agree with people we like and, just as important, the propensity for others to agree with us, if we like them.
  • Authority: We are more likely to say “yes” to others who are authorities, who carry greater knowledge, experience or expertise.
  • Scarcity: We want more of what is less available or dwindling in availability.

So can we use these principles to enthuse our dancers?  Or, from a moral viewpoint, should we use them.  I don't see why not.  They're being used on us all the time, to persuade us to buy products, to pay more than we should for things we don't really want, and so on; why shouldn't we use them to make dancers more enthusiastic about our form of dancing?!

  This is a workshop not a lecture, so I would ask people for their ideas on how to apply each principle before giving mine, and they would probably come up with some I'd never thought of.

Reciprocation

If you give the dancers something, they'll feel they have to give you something in return.  But what can you give them?  Well, you can give them praise when they've done something well.  Everyone likes praise, provided it's genuine and not cheap flattery.  Just coming down on the floor to show someone how to do a double figure eight or a set and link is giving them something too, and can generate a lot of good-will, not just from the person you're helping but from others who might also have been confused, and from those who appreciate the fact that you're willing to come amongst them and put yourself in their place rather than just being a god-like presence on the stage.  I recently guided a new dancer through a double figure eight and suddenly she saw what the words meant.  And I then walked her track so that she could see the “8” pattern it made on the floor, and I also walked the other woman's track to show that that was also an “8”.  If you're a caller who thinks “waste of good dancing time” I'm afraid I can't help you — to me it was “good teaching time”.

Commitment and Consistency

Once people have a particular image of themselves, they automatically act so as to confirm that image.  As Shakespeare's Hamlet says, “Assume a virtue, if you have it not”, and each time you do the virtuous thing it becomes easier and more natural.  So if you tell people that they're doing a great job of fitting the dance to the music, they start to think of themselves as “someone who dances to the music” and therefore they try harder to live up to that image.  Again, don't say it if it's obviously not true, but provided they've made some attempt I don't see why you shouldn't use this form of encouragement.  I realise it won't convince everyone, but don't let that stop you.  I remember once at Pinewoods Camp in the States someone saying to me, “Colin, you got us dancing better than we could”.  I think what he meant was that I went into it with the attitude of “You're good dancers — of course you can do this”, and that gave them a self-image to live up to — which they did.  In my experience dancers live up to the leader's expectations — or down to them.

Social Proof

If a lot of people are doing something, it must be the right thing to do.  We all know that!  For instance, in the States, whether it's a contra dance or an English dance, what you do at the end of each dance is “Thank this partner and find another”.  There are very few who will break this rule — and you don't take someone to a dance on a first date, because the group's expectation is that you will only dance with them a few times.  But in England a lot of people dance with one partner the whole evening, and if I try to get people to change partners occasionally I'm met with a lot of resistance — the Social Proof is against me.  I'm not suggesting you take on that battle, but how can you use this principle to your advantage as a caller?  I believe that if you teach something, such as fitting the figure to the music, then get them to try it, then (assuming it's true) say “Most of you are doing that really well”, this will encourage the doubters to go along with the majority and make a greater effort to fit the figure to the music.  As I keep saying, you won't convince everyone, but give it a go and you might be surprised at the results.

Liking

If people like you, they're much more likely to do what you want them to do.  This is a difficult one.  Some people like me and will travel quite a distance to go to a dance or workshop of mine.  Some people don't like me and wouldn't dream of going.  I speak my mind, and some people don't like that — they think that I'm rude and I pick on people.  There are callers who project a totally false self-image, but I can't or won't do that.  There are certainly times when I think “I wish I hadn't said that”, and if possible I then apologise to the person either publicly or privately.  I suppose my real recommendation is to be aware of how you're coming across to the dancers, but that's not easy.  Do you have a friend who will give you some honest feedback?  Many people are loath to criticise, so you need to make it clear to them that you really want their honest opinion — saying “You were wonderful” may be nice to hear but it doesn't help you improve!

It's also a good idea to smile!  I'm not good at that — if I'm amused I smile and laugh, but I can't just switch it on the way some people do.  Do as I say, not as I do!

Authority

As the caller you're assumed to have authority — to know what you're doing and be able to tell the dancers what to do.  But we all know people — politicians in particular — who abuse their authority and then people don't believe a word they say.  My view is that you should be quietly confident rather than giving out the message “I'm in charge so you do what I say”.  In another section of notes I mention Steven Covey's distinction between a Manager and a Leader.  People follow a Manager because they're being paid to do so and they don't want to prejudice their working life.  People follow a Leader because they trust her and believe in what she's doing.  And of course a caller is a Leader — there's no compulsion on the dancers to do what you say, and if you force them they probably won't come to another of your events.  So use your authority wisely.  I try not to be dogmatic in my pronouncements: I say “This is the way I do it, but other people will tell you differently”.  If people question me I don't feel that they're undermining my authority; they're just asking a question and usually I can explain why the way I teach something works better, but there are certainly occasions when I've changed my mind because I realised I didn't have any basis for my opinion other than “that's the way I've always done it”.  Don't think you'll lose your authority if you admit that someone else has made a good point!  Most Managers will never admit they were wrong: again politicians are a good example but you'll find it in all organisations.  A Leader is always willing to consider other opinions and change her mind if appropriate, and people are more likely to respect you for this than to think your authority has been undermined.

Scarcity

“Special offer — 80% off — today only” — we've all seen this sort of advertising hundreds of times.  “Only 2 flights available at this price”, and so on.  I'm struggling to think of any way for you to apply this!  Of course there are perfectly genuine examples, such as a top caller from abroad who is only appearing at one festival, but I don't think you, as a caller, can invent some kind of special offer or scarcity.  Never mind — I hope I've given you enough to think about with the other five principles.

I do suggest you read the book — he gives some absolutely amazing examples of scientific studies which have been done to show these six principles in action!